Destructive vs non-destructive testing

Destructive vs Non-Destructive Testing

Destructive testing (DT) and non-destructive testing (NDT) are two distinct test methods for evaluating & testing the properties (mechanical, chemical or physical) and integrity of materials or structures.

Destructive testing (DT) involves subjecting a test specimen taken from material to an external force or condition that causes damage or failure, rendering it unusable for further testing or application/use. Non-destructive testing (NDT), on the other hand, aims to inspect to find presence or absence of flaws in the material or structure without causing permanent damage and material can be reused after testing.

Destructive testing involves subjecting a part or test coupon to an external load, pressure, or temperature that exceeds its maximum capacity, resulting in a physical change or damage that renders the specimen unusable for further testing or application. Examples of destructive testing methods include tension, compression, bending, and shear tests.

On the other hand, non-destructive testing (NDT) aims to inspect the material or structure without causing any permanent changes or damages. NDT methods use various techniques such as visual inspection, ultrasonic testing, magnetic particle inspection, radiography, and eddy current testing, among others. NDT is typically used for quality control, safety inspection, and failure analysis purposes.

NDT other meaning are NDI (non-destructive inspection) and NDE (nondestructive evaluation), although all these words mean same i.e., Non- Destructive Testing.

Destructive Testing (DT):

  • Involves the alteration or destruction of the test specimen
  • Typically used for material property evaluation, quality control, and failure analysis
  • Provides accurate and quantitative data
  • Test results are not always applicable to the entire batch
See also  Can we use E6010 or E61013 in place of E7018 or E7024

Examples:

  1. Tensile testing
  2. Bend testing
  3. Hardness testing
  4. Impact testing
  5. Metallographic examination

Non-destructive Testing (NDT):

  • Test specimen remains unaltered and undamaged
  • Typically used for inspection and defect detection in finished products and components
  • Provides qualitative or sometimes quantitative data
  • Allows for testing of the entire batch or in-service components

Examples:

  1. Ultrasonic testing
  2. Radiographic testing
  3. Magnetic particle testing
  4. Liquid penetrant testing
  5. Visual inspection
AspectDestructive TestingNon-destructive Testing
Test SpecimenAltered or destroyedUnaltered and undamaged
Primary UseMaterial property evaluationInspection and defect detection
DataAccurate and quantitativeQualitative or sometimes quantitative
Applicability to BatchTest results may not apply to entire batchAllows for testing of entire batch or in-service components
ExamplesTensile testing, Bend testingUltrasonic testing, Radiographic testing

NDT vs. DT: Objective vs Applications

DT or Destructive Testing is typically used when the specimen’s failure is required to understand its mechanical properties or to verify its design parameters. The main advantage of DT is that it provides accurate and reliable data on the specimen’s performance under extreme conditions, making it useful for materials development and research as actual material is subjected to test conditions.

NDT is typically used for quality control, safety inspection, and failure analysis purposes. The main advantage of NDT is that it allows for the detection of hidden defects or flaws in the specimen (without breaking the material), which would not be visible with visual inspection. NDT is also cost-effective since it doesn’t require the destruction of the specimen, and it provides valuable information on the specimen’s health, helping to prevent accidents or failures.

See also  How to calculate and estimate Welding Cost?

Following table sum-up the differences between Destructive testing and non-destructive testing.

Destructive Testing (DT)Non-Destructive Testing (NDT)Causes damage or failure, rendering specimen unusableDoes not cause permanent damage to the specimen.
Examples: tension, compression, bending, shear testsExamples: visual inspection, ultrasonic testing, magnetic particle inspection, radiography, eddy current testing
Provides accurate data on mechanical properties and failure under extreme conditionsDetects hidden defects or flaws, preventing accidents or failures
Used for materials development and researchUsed for quality control, safety inspection, and failure analysis
Accurate and reliable dataCost-effective
Dependent on material and testing requirementsDoes not cause permanent damage to the specimen

Related Posts on Destructive Testing

Related Posts on Non-Destructive Testing

Material Welding is run by highly experienced welding engineers, welding trainers & ASNT NDT Level III bloggers. We strive to provide most accurate and practical knowledge in welding, metallurgy, NDT and Engineering domains.